If you find yourself in Buffalo, NY, Emergency Pizza is a must-visit pizza restaurant that promises not only mouthwatering pies but also a delightful dining experience. Nestled at 1870 Seneca St, this establishment has captured the hearts of locals and visitors alike.
Many customers, like ZAKTHEBEAST403 and Matthew S, rave about the deliciousness of the pizza, highlighting its exceptional taste and the warm hospitality of owner Jim. Multiple reviews describe the pizza's balanced sauce, perfectly cooked crust, and generous toppings like cup pepperoni. Reviewers like Dave Wright appreciate quick service without compromising quality, and the spot is adored as a reliable late-night option by Renee Jindra.
The inviting atmosphere and friendly staff, including Chris, who is celebrated for his enthusiasm, enhance the overall customer experience. With consistent praise and a strong reputation in the South Buffalo area, it’s no wonder Emergency Pizza tops the list for pizza lovers. Whether you're a local or just passing through, a visit to Emergency Pizza will undoubtedly satiate your cravings and leave you longing for more.
Amenities and More
Accessibility
No wheelchair-accessible car park
No wheelchair-accessible entrance
No wheelchair-accessible seating
Service options
Has no-contact delivery
Offers delivery
Offers takeaway
Serves dine-in
Popular for
Popular for lunch
Popular for dinner
Good for solo dining
Offerings
Serves comfort food
Serves late-night food
Quick bite
Dining options
Serves lunch
Serves dinner
Amenities
No toilet
Atmosphere
Casual
Crowd
Popular with university students
Planning
Doesn't accept reservations
Payments
Accepts credit cards
Accepts debit cards
Accepts NFC mobile payments
Credit cards
Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot
Somewhat difficult to find a space
Photos
Reviews For Emergency Pizza
ZAKTHEBEAST403
Jun 5,2025
Pizza is delicious got a party pizza for my dad first time getting from here and Jim the owner is an absolute delight to talk to. Jim you know what you did thank you sir!
Matthew S
Jun 1,2025
My wife and I were in buffalo for the ravens/buffalo playoff game and decided to swing into emergency pizza, the owner was awesome! We talked for over 20 minutes! The pizza was the best pizza I’ve ever had in my life, I will 1000000% be back to emergency pizza
Dave Wright
May 29,2025
We moved to this area and started with Emergency pizza. We walked in and was greeted. They offered two slices and a drink deal. We settled on a large cheese and pepperoni. We got our pizza fairly quick. We were very happy to have cup pepperoni. Cheese and sauce we're well balanced. Sauce wasn't super sweet and served the pizza well. Dough and crust we're firm but enjoyable through the whole pizza. Overall we three agreed this pizza was great and we look forward to the next order!
Renee Jindra
May 20,2025
Emergency is our late night go to pizza place. On august 31st we ordered our regular, large cheese pepperoni and banana pepper. It was by far, the best pizza I have gotten from anywhere in the south buffalo area. We have ordered from all the pizzerias in our neighborhood, but emergency holds the #1 spot. Great pizza. Clean sauce perfect toppings and a strong well cooked crust. Consistently delicious pies. Thank you Emergency!!
Charlie Lewis
Apr 22,2025
First time here. Chris served us, the enthusiasm, conversation, and professionalism were off the charts. Thank you.
Structure Ism
Apr 10,2025
Hands down some of the best food in the pizza and wings sector of this wonderful City. The pizza is stunning fresh and portions are awesome. The wings are absolutely amazing jumbo and perfectly sauced. I have tried a number of the specialty items as well, that you typically don't find in many pizzerias .... The house made jumbo meatballs are stunning whether you get them with the spaghetti or on a sub. --- The barbecue ribs are perfect juicy falling off the bone and melt in your mouth. --- The Friday fish fry is one of the best I have had anywhere in the city. --- DeVille parmesan and chicken parmesan are also absolutely stunning. Large portions and perfectly seasoned with plenty of cheese and herbs. --- The eggplant parmesan was a big surprise it was absolutely bursting with flavor and a very nice portion size. --- I have had a few of their subs over time always super fresh , flavorful with hefty portions of meat that I'm told are sliced fresh ... that must be the case because these are some of the best subs in the city. --- And the best thing about this restaurant is that they are open until 2:00 a.m. !!!!!! Not many options at all after 10:00 p.m. in Buffalo anymore. --- The only downfall is they add a 4% charge on orders after 10:00 p.m. which makes no sense to me at all. Also , their hefylty delivery charge is between three and five dollars depending on your distance from the location.
Jayna Drury
Mar 22,2025
I grew up in the northtowns and when I moved to south buffalo it was quite the journey to find decent pizza. Emergency is by far the best in south buffalo. Cooked to perfection everytime. Consistent and delicious. The pictures on my shitty camera don't do it justice.
Marie Kroll
Mar 18,2025
Ordered and my food came in less than an hour late at night at a busy time which I live, I think about 20 minutes from there so i think that a really quick, food was cooked perfectly and delicious. I got the garlic bread with tomatoes and cheese and 10 wings half-and-half. I got barbecue and medium. Everything was great driver was very friendly. The app was nice and easy to use to place my order
Reviews For Emergency Pizza